PDA

View Full Version : Are converts more zealous?


Booko
11-06-2009, 10:54 AM
What's your own personal experience with conversion and those who've converted from the beliefs they were raised with?

Are you a convert yourself? Do you think it makes you more active in your faith (or lack thereof)?

(It's very hard for me to say much about this myself, as almost all Baha'is are converts here anyway so there's my situation is kinda anomalous.)

This study only appears to cover Christians in the U.S., but read the details further on, as you might find them interesting.

A common perception about individuals who switch religions is that they are very fervent about their new faith. A new analysis by the Pew Research Center's Forum on Religion & Public Life provides quantitative support for this piece of conventional wisdom often referred to as the "zeal of the convert."


The analysis finds that people who have switched faiths (or joined a faith after being raised unaffiliated with a religion) are indeed slightly more religious than those who have remained in their childhood faith, as measured by the importance of religion in their lives, the frequency with which they attend religious services and other measures of religious commitment.


However, the analysis also finds that the differences in religious commitment between converts1 (http://pewresearch.org/pubs/1392/greater-zeal-of-religious-converts-is-real-but-modest#fn1)and nonconverts are generally very small and are more apparent among some religious groups2 (http://pewresearch.org/pubs/1392/greater-zeal-of-religious-converts-is-real-but-modest#fn2) than among others.


One of the most striking findings of the U.S. Religious Landscape Survey (http://religions.pewforum.org/), conducted by the Pew Forum in 2007, was the large number of people who have left their childhood faith.
According to the survey, roughly half of all Americans say they have left the faith in which they were raised to adopt another faith or no faith at all, or if they were not raised in a religion, they have since joined one.

The new analysis finds that, overall, people who have switched religions consistently exhibit higher levels of religious commitment than those who still belong to their childhood faith, but the differences are relatively modest.
Full article here (http://pewresearch.org/pubs/1392/greater-zeal-of-religious-converts-is-real-but-modest).

beckysoup61
11-07-2009, 07:08 PM
Personally, I'd say yes.

These people have researched, and thought out and chosen this path. Those of us who were born into it haven't had that same chance, though many do reaffirm their born faith later in life.

Booko
11-07-2009, 07:30 PM
Personally, I'd say yes.

These people have researched, and thought out and chosen this path. Those of us who were born into it haven't had that same chance, though many do reaffirm their born faith later in life.

I wonder though, how it compares to those who have dropped away from the faith they were raised in and then later returned. That is, can you "convert" to the same faith you were raised in? I think so.

As children we don't and even can't conceive of things the way adults can. I'm reminded of St. Paul's remarks in 1 Corinthians about childish things.

I can recall very clearly my childish view of Christianity. Then I hit the developmental stage where you start to reason, and that childish form of religion had to give way to an adult form or it would go away. In my case it certainly went away.

Now that I'm adult, and when I relooked at Christ through more experienced eyes things look very very different.

If I hadn't run across Baha'u'llah I might've given Christianity another shot to see if I could make it work as the faith of an adult. As it is, I don't find much motivation to try Christianity, since from a Baha'i perspective I get to be a Baha'i and keep Christ anyway. :shrug:

Ğanisty
11-09-2009, 09:28 AM
I think it really depends on a lot of things, including what religion you convert to. Some denominations seem to encourage zealous behavior more than others so if you convert to one of those, I'm sure the tendencies are much stronger.

I guess we'd have to decide what makes a person zealous as opposed to devout. I would think most people who have converted to a religion have done so because it speaks to them and they feel very strongly about it. That's not necessarily the same thing as zealous though. I've met a lot of people (for instance many Southern Baptists) who are zealous in the religion they were raised in.

Rasta
11-11-2009, 03:42 PM
I grew up as a fundimental Christian. When I became an apostate, I was fervant in my efforts to tell the world of their folly! Then I thought about it (after a while), and realized my behavior was stupid. I was angry. Angry at whom? I was angry at god. Wait a second, I don't believe in god, that doesn't make sense. I was angry at Christians for lying to me. That doesn't make sense either. They didn't think they were lying. The vast majority are doing their best to get by, just like me.

I realized that my behavior was a remnant of my previous belief. I became more zen, more cheerful, and had a much more positive outlook on life.

Zephyr
11-11-2009, 03:57 PM
Probably. Back in my "Christian" days I was really pretty damn apathetic. That coulda been just because I was a kid though.